It’s almost Christmas again and I’ve hardly written anything this year, well I’ve hardly written any fiction. I’ve been too busy with other non-fiction stuff (mostly programming related projects) and have spent a lot of my spare time on my Indie games programming.
Hopefully 2014 is the year I get my OtherWhere stories finished once and for all, maybe then I can try and actually do something with them… or not.
I don’t get book-tokens for Christmas anymore, but the pre-paid Waterstones and Smiths cards are already arriving (so I can buy myself something I’d like for Christmas), isn’t progress wonderful.
Once again I can unwrap the books I’ve bought, from them to me, on the 25th and get a big surprise… well to be fair my family and friends do all know my memory is really bad.
The thing is I’ve no idea what to get this year. There’s the latest DiskWorld book of course, but I will be getting that as part of my presents from my wife… which is why I haven’t bought it already.
I’m changing jobs at the end of January as well, so I’ll probably need some more programming books, but I’m loathed to get these as someone’s present to me –looks of disappointment and confusion generally follow this, as they’ve told me to ‘buy something nice.’
So any ideas on what good Fantasy/SF books are out there?
What is Santa bringing you?
Hello and welcome to my Blog.
This, mostly, consists of my thoughts and ramblings on writing in general, and occasionally to my own writings in particular: but don’t let that put you off...
Custom Search
Thursday, 19 December 2013
Friday, 25 October 2013
Being creative…
I haven’t written much in this blog for a while, but then I
haven’t written much fiction at all for a while. It’s not that I've eventually
came to my senses, decided I'm not good enough, will never catch a break, and decided
to do something less ethereal with my limited time or anything, err nothing ‘normal’
like that…
But I have been productive. I’ve been spending most of my
free-time, which isn’t much, on my other ‘hobby’ recently… Ah, yes, you noticed
the quotes did you. I was always under the impression that hobbies were
supposed to be something you did to relax. Well my hobby is writing, writing fictional
stories, and writing computer games, the type of thing that is referred to as
Indie. And the latter has largely taken my attention away from the former over
the best part of the past year... Although I have done a bit of writing, honest.
I read a few blogs on why people write recently. It’s always
an interesting subject because, although you do get the same old tropes rearing
up, every single person has a different take on what makes them write, or be
creative. I've also noticed that there seems to be an ever-increasing number of
people seriously intent on becoming a fiction Author out there. Not that I’m
saying that’s a bad thing by any means. Perhaps I lucky to have an established career
away from fiction writing, or perhaps this is a safety-net that stops me taking
it more seriously than a hobby and pipe dream. Although I honestly don’t think I’m good
enough to make a living out of it anyway, which brings me back to my other
writing hobby, writing games programs… And it is writing, and it is creative. I
program computer applications for a living and am often amazed at how dry
people perceive this to be, compared to the similarities I find with fiction
writing. You have to design things in your mind and write them out in a format
that works for other people, you have to design your output to appeal to people
and to be easy to take in and understand, and most of all you need to be
creative.
And I think that’s the root of why I like to write, it’s why
I like to make Indie computer games, and why I have an avid interest in art; and
like to draw and paint, although I’ll never be all that good; it’s because, even
though none of it is ever going to make me rich or famous, I am a naturally
creative person, and sadly not everyone is. To be honest if the point of someone’s
writing, or doing any of the things I mentioned, is solely to make money I
think they must be forcing it and surely there must be much better, and easier, ways for
most people to make money. But hay, if they have the talent and skill why not. People
do jobs they don’t particularly like every day, for most of their lives…
I'm by no means bread-line poor, and would quite like to be comfortably-well-off,
but I don’t think I’d like to be famous, and nowadays writers tend to be ‘sold’
as a commodity much more than before. I’d like to eventually finish my OtherWhere
stories in one form or another, and would be quite happy if they were moderately
successful. I still have some games to finish off, but next year will be the
year I get back to fiction writing and finish off those stories, even if nobody
else on the planet notices. I do think the ‘hobbyist’ is generally being squeezed
out, scoffed at and looked down upon a bit more in general now though,
especially in on-line writing sites. I don’t know why because some of the best literature
came from people who, at least initially, saw what they were doing as a hobby
or pastime. But if you are a serious beginner write, I sincerely wish you the
best of luck… And know you are going to need it.
Friday, 17 May 2013
Interactive Literature
People have been talking about fiction becoming interactive since the inception of the ‘text-based adventure game.’ I recently come across an essay written in the 1989, purely by chance, and soon realised that nothing much has really changed in the general public’s attitudes to this medium from then till now, which is surprising really, as our general attitudes to pretty much every other aspect of computing has changed.
I remember spending many hours of my youth playing these text-based adventure games, and have probably spent more time on this type of program than on any other. I remember eagerly awaiting the release of the next Scott Adams Adventure game for my VIC-20, then later drooling over the hype machines from the likes of Level 9, Infocom, and Magnetic Scrolls, to name but a few. And make no mistake, these games releases were major events, with many people more than ready to part with their cash for the next game in a series or for the latest brand new story. The best-selling text-based adventure games were easily amongst the bestselling entertainment software of their day, and it very much was about the story and its, often reoccurring, characters. This was a recognized gamming genre that only seemed set to stay and grow with time. Then everything changed. As computer gaming become gradually more mainstream the emphasis was firmly placed on graphics and easy to access gameplay. By the time of the Sony Playstation heralded in an era of 3D gameplay for everyone, the traditional text-based adventure game was already commercially dead and largely forgotten by the general games-playing public.
Thursday, 16 May 2013
Dan Brown - An Inferno in a Tea-Cup?
I’m only a little ways into the book at the time of writing this, but it’s already abundantly clear that this is exactly what I thought it would be, more of the same formula. If that sounds a bit dismissive it isn’t meant to be. As I said, I liked the formula. I liked the last books. They were simple adventurous fun ‘fluff,’ but what’s wrong with that? I liked the previous stories and I liked what I’ve read of this one. I will finish it, smile, put it down, and forget about it until the next one comes out… Just like I did with the rest, and there is nothing wrong with that. I suppose this series can be my ‘Hary Potter’ or dare I say it even my ‘Twilight’ (shudder)…
It’s not rocket-science, it’s not high-brow, and it probably won’t ever be seen as ‘literature’ whatever that’s meant to be. But it is a good crowed pleasing story, and yet more proof, if it were ever needed, that precise clinical ‘literary’ writing we are all told to practice isn’t necessarily what the general public (the people I actually seen one critique refer to as ‘the unwashed masses,’ tells you bucket-loads about the reviewer that does) really want, what they want is a good story…
… then in our hearts I think we all know that, so good luck to Mr Brown.
Wednesday, 20 February 2013
Working Draft Cover Idea…
This is the working draft of my cover Idea for a book comprising of three of my Novella length OtherWhere stories.
I’d appreciate any comments, but would especially like comments on what type of story you think this is illustrating, what demographic you think it may appeal to, and whether or not it looks eye-catching enough. Also, do you think it still looks OK thumb-nailed and in full?
It does what I wrote in my description, but… Does it look ‘professional’ enough or too amateur… I honestly can’t tell with cover art!
Thursday, 31 January 2013
I did something a newbie writer should never really do today…
… I had a slow day at work, so I went on-line and read all the reader’s reviews/comments on my work, on as much different sites as I could see.
Now I’m a bit happy, a bit disheartened, and a lot confused.
The good news is that some readers game me top marks! The bad news is some gave me bottom marks… The slightly better news is that there are more top marks than there are bottom ones, and a fair portion of middling scores as well.
So what do all these scores tell me? Well possibly not anything we don’t all already know before looking at stuff like this. Some people will like our writing, some won’t, and others will say “Meh…” and go on to the next. I did read some very well thought out and cohesive reviews though; and some one line ‘this is rubbish’ / ‘this is great’ stuff, that doesn’t say much; some of which gave me as much insight as a good critique, pointing out both good and bad things from the readers’ point of view. These will all be helpful, as I’m building on one of these stories to be included in something much larger that I’m currently in the middle of writing.
Reading this stuff definitely brings home the reality of letting the public loos on your story. People will hate it, with luck some may love it, and most will be mildly interested to ambivalent. If this third group read to the end and actually recommend it to others I count that as a win, and some did. What you do get are real unregulated responses from people who, for the most part, do not write themselves. So; as long as you bring a large spoonful of salt, and a very thick skin with you; there is some genuine experience to be gained from doing this, just remember to fight the urge to respond, however strong it may be, or how misjudged or put-upon you may feel. Remember these are not tame critters, these are the ‘readers in the wild’ and cornering one may set the pack on you.
Monday, 28 January 2013
Judging a book by its cover...
Of course we all know the old axiom, don’t judge a book by its
cover, and we all know that there is an entire industry dedicated to making
people do exactly this.
At this point in commercial fiction publishing, I think it’s
fair to say they the industry has ether intentionally or by accident created a
certain expectation of what cover art should look like, and perhaps more
importantly what it should look like for each genre.
People primarily lift a book up of the shelf for one of two reasons, ether because of the author’s name, or because of the cover design.
I believe there are certain characteristics that now say ‘Romance Novell,’ ‘Thriller,’ “Scienc Fiction,’ ‘Fantasy,’ and ‘Horror.’
Yes, of course any potential reader/customer may be able to tell the genre by the book’s name, or by the picture illustration used, but it’s deeper than this...
I believe there are certain characteristics that now say ‘Romance Novell,’ ‘Thriller,’ “Scienc Fiction,’ ‘Fantasy,’ and ‘Horror.’
Yes, of course any potential reader/customer may be able to tell the genre by the book’s name, or by the picture illustration used, but it’s deeper than this...
Look at all the crime/thriller novels, for example. They do
have a certain ‘look,’ or template that is different
from the average romance of
SciFi-Fantasy book. And, perversely, if a beginner writer or self e-publisher wants
their book to ‘stand out from the crowd’ they also have to get a cover design
that ‘fits in nicely’ with this self same throng. Because if they don’t the conditioned
book buying public may subconsciously pass their work by based solely on the
unspoken notion that it ‘doesn’t fit’ what they are looking for.
Tuesday, 27 November 2012
Why don’t dyslexic writers untie?
Quite by accident I recently come across a news story about
a dyslexic boy winning a national writing contest, but the fact that this was
seen, and reported, as almost miraculous news made me think about people’s perceptions
about dyslexics and writing in general... Not that I’m belittling or taking
away from this boy’s achievement in any shape or form, he’s obviously much
better than I was at that age (and probably still am) and has a great deal of
potential to become a good writer. But it’s not ‘in spite of his dyslexia’ it’s
because he inherently shows promise as a writer.
I really got strong undertones of the normal ‘Aww, didn’t he do well’ arrogance,
accompanied by a metaphorical, if not possibly even physical, head-pat. Well, yes,
he did do well. He did well because he’s probably already a better writer than
most of the cooing condescending onlookers can or will ever be. So why don’t
they have that attitude with non-dyslexics? I even read one report that talked
about him ‘overcoming his learning-disability’ with the inference being that he
was able to compete with ‘normal’ students... Aww,
didn’t he do well.
A
little further digging showed that this instance was far from an isolated case. Someone
with dyslexia winning writing or literary awards isn’t that an unusual occurrence.
It seems to be far more common than you may expect, but still, on each occasion
the story is based on the fact that they are dyslexic, not on their
achievement. It saddens me to think that we may not have moved the public
perception on much since my terrible time at school. It’s attitudes
like this that put me in remedial classes from primary school. I was eventually
able to educate myself to post-grad level after leaving school, by being able
to do things my own way. I don’t personally see this as exceptional, although I also got the 'didn’t he do well' attitude. I think it’s
simply something they should have helped me with at school, although there obviously are
truly exceptional dyslexics out there, Richard Branson to name but one.
Monday, 19 November 2012
It’s almost Christmas again, and I’ve hardly wrote a thing this year...
Other things seem to have taken over my life a bit lately; pushing
my writing into a very poor second, or sometimes a sad third; still, at least I
know what my new-year’s resolution will be. I’ve been thinking of ways to get
myself ‘back on the horse’ lately as I think a bit of a metaphorical, or possibly
physical, kick would get me up to speed again.
With this in mind I’ve discovered a few writers groups that aren’t too far way. I’m just not sure about approaching them. Is there an entrance requirement? Do I have to saunter up cap-in-hand and say “Hello, my name’s Garry and I’m a writer?” Would my cap-full of short-story publications and extensive collection of rejection letters be enough to prove this?
With this in mind I’ve discovered a few writers groups that aren’t too far way. I’m just not sure about approaching them. Is there an entrance requirement? Do I have to saunter up cap-in-hand and say “Hello, my name’s Garry and I’m a writer?” Would my cap-full of short-story publications and extensive collection of rejection letters be enough to prove this?
Seriously though, writers groups and writing courses have
always held a bit of a fascination and more than a touch of mystery to me.
Although I have had 'professional' writing experience as part of my work, you could say
I’m pretty much self-taught as far as fiction writing is concerned, having never
had any formal fiction writing education or tuition. I wouldn’t want to find
myself in the middle of a classically educated ‘literary’ crowd, where I’d
probably feel like I was trying to write ‘Janet and John’ books to their ‘War
and Peace.’
I’d be interested in people’s experiences or perceptions of
writing groups and of formal writing courses, whether they are distance-learning
or college based.
Do all on-line or mail-based courses fall into the ‘We can
make you into a PUBLISHED writer in 60 days!!!!!’ category or are there genuine
legitimate ones that are worthwhile?
What’s your experience with college/university based
courses, whether they lead to a qualification or not, are they more or less worthwhile?
And not to forget those writers groups and workshops, are
they helpful, and who is likely to attend?
Monday, 15 October 2012
Writing for fun or profit
Yes, ok I’ve heard the old ‘people who only try writing to
make a quick profit will never make it’ truisms many times before, and I’m sure
most ‘wanna be’ or beginner writers would agree with this. You have to want to
write first, and then want to become good enough at the craft through diligent practice
and learning to become publishable. And although everyone’s definition of ‘publishable’
is different, it’s only really the editors/publishers definition that matters.
I may be wrong here, but I seem to have noticed a distinct
lack of the ‘fun’ part amongst the new wave of ‘beginners’ lately. Now, to set
the scene, I would consider myself a beginner writer, and have done so for at
least the past ten years. I say I’m a beginner because during this time I’ve
only just scuffed the surface of the magical mystical publishable barrier.
Although I would consider the substance (telling a cohesive story) and the technicality
(the craft aspect) of my writing to have improved during that time I will
always still see this as learning until the increasingly unlikely event of me
getting a publishing deal. It’s the last level of fine punctuation and grammar editing
that remained my biggest bug-bear, and I can’t afford to personally employ a professional
editor. But hey, that’s just me being grumpy again.
Monday, 9 July 2012
Book Festivals, good bad or indifferent?
I’ve been browsing through the latest events list for the
Edinburgh Book festival again this year, and as usual I’ll probably try to
attend something. I’ve generally turned up for at least a passing look at what’s
happening most years for longer than I care to remember. Although I’ve seen
some interesting things during that time, my most abiding memory of events-past
is being stuck at work and missing the Terry Pratchett talk, something I really
would have liked to attend ever since picking up a brand new just-of-the-press
hardback copy of ‘The Reaper Man’ way back in my college years.
But is that the thing. Are they just pandering to our
misty-eyed remembrances? Or to the poke-it-with-a-stick interest we have in the
lives of the famous or controversial figures that generally turn up to promote
their autobiographies etc. Is there still real merit to Book Festivals in our modern
digital age?
One thing I have noticed is that there seems to be a lot
more emphasis on promoting new authors this time around, something that has admittedly
been growing over the last few years. Surely that can only be a good thing. As
normal the ‘recognisable names’ are there. Paddy Ashdown’s talk on “WHY THE
WORLD WILL NEVER BE THE SAME AGAIN” seemed
to sell out quickly (shouting capitals
and all!) while the more ‘literary’ based events take a bit longer to sell.
Yes, I know that’s just the way things are. But it does make me wonder who is
attending these events nowadays, and why. Are they avid book readers, does it
matter? Should these festivals be trying to pull in the off-the-street punters?
I would say yes, they should, the more ‘diverse’
the merrier. But when you sit in the book festival beer-tent and look around
you see a very different crowed to those attending the seemingly less hi-brow
events.
I see people sitting in bars or on benches or on a bus with
kindles now, but I don’t think the majority of these readers would ever consider
browsing around the book festival. It’s a perception thing, but I also don’t
think the look and attitude of many of the attendees help maters ether.
So what do you think? Is there a future for book festivals
in general?
Are they still relevant to our modern reading habits?
Wednesday, 4 April 2012
Writing in tongues. (Part 2)
I recently read an interesting article about fantasy writing
on the BBC magazine site.
The article, titled ‘Why are fantasy world accents British?’ looks primarily at TV
shows and film, and explores the peculiar phenomenon of why most fantasy characters
speak with Brittish accents, but its arguments and logic can equally as well be
applied to the written word.
The article gives examples of the ‘Game of Thrones’ TV
series, taken from the books of the American author George RR Martin, and the
blockbusting ‘Lord of the Rings’ and upcoming ‘Hobbit’ films in support of its
argument.
I think it does make a compelling case for appropriate regional
accents, and it goes someway towards explaining why America audiences in particular,
and the world in general, seem to like British-English voices in their fantasy
fiction.
I read this article not long after receiving the news that
one of my own short-stories written in my native Scottish vernacular (that I posted about before) is likely
to be published in an upcoming anthology of ‘Scottish Voice’ stories. On
reading the article I was reminded of the overwhelmingly positive response a
draft version my own story got from American readers when I posted it to a critique
site...
Friday, 30 March 2012
The lean, meme, writing machine...
It's a, sort of, history of the Anonymous Hacker group and their rise to... notoriety, lets say... through the 4chan image-board network.
The book is a decent read if you like this type of thing, but that's not what this post is about. You see the first few chapters of this book explore memes in general and internet memes in particular.

That's probably one of the most widespread Internet memes 'alive' today, and it was birthed from the rather fetid hive-mind that is 4chan.
Please don't be too tempted to go have a look though, as there are certain things you just can't un-see...
Anyway all this talk of memes got me thinking about how much our current memes are imbedded in today's writings, especially fiction writing. I think a lot of modern memes are present both in the finished stories and in the way we are now taught, or told, to write.
Monday, 12 March 2012
Anyone can be a writer!
...Or at least that's what a lot of the 'How To' books would have you
believe.
I read in the blurb of one such book that 'anyone who can write a letter can write a Novel.' But after looking at the ever-increasing pile of rejection notifications and 'one star' reviews I think most wannabe writers could be forgiven for being little sceptical of this advice.
Writing is a craft, and crafts can be learned and mastered. So in one real sense anyone could become a writer, that isn't a lie. But I don't think it necessarily means that anyone who can compose a decent letter can write a Novel. It's like saying anyone who can drive a car could become a top formula 1 racing driver. Maybe in theory they could, but unless they have the drive, not to mention nerves of steel, they won't get far in practice...
I read in the blurb of one such book that 'anyone who can write a letter can write a Novel.' But after looking at the ever-increasing pile of rejection notifications and 'one star' reviews I think most wannabe writers could be forgiven for being little sceptical of this advice.
Writing is a craft, and crafts can be learned and mastered. So in one real sense anyone could become a writer, that isn't a lie. But I don't think it necessarily means that anyone who can compose a decent letter can write a Novel. It's like saying anyone who can drive a car could become a top formula 1 racing driver. Maybe in theory they could, but unless they have the drive, not to mention nerves of steel, they won't get far in practice...
Saturday, 3 March 2012
Is there anybody out there?
I've just noticed a rather drastic drop in my monthly page-view count this month.
For the last eight months it's mostly been a good few hundred posts over a thousand, and never fallen below.
last month it was only just over 200! Has something changed with blogger, or with any major site that links on to posts in blogger?
Surely my blogs can't have got that bad that quickley?
Anybody else noticed a drop in their page-views last month? Have I missed something?
For the last eight months it's mostly been a good few hundred posts over a thousand, and never fallen below.
last month it was only just over 200! Has something changed with blogger, or with any major site that links on to posts in blogger?
Surely my blogs can't have got that bad that quickley?
Anybody else noticed a drop in their page-views last month? Have I missed something?
Monday, 27 February 2012
Writing-aide applications, are they any good?
I was reading thorough some blogs and forums lately and
noticed a few people talking about some of the programs they use to help with
their writing. From what I made out there are two main types of programs, the
ones that are intended to help with the technicalities of your writing and the
ones that let you store and organise both your writing and your ideas.
Now, the only application I’ve ever used to help with my
writing is MS word, and the benefits of that ‘helping’ are dubious at best. Ok,
so the built-in thesaurus is sometimes worth its weight in gold, and I do use
the spell-checker... but I’ve learned that I should definitely not rely on it.
I’m not too sure about it’s concepts of grammar and punctuation ether. And that
leads me into the programs purporting to help with your technical writing. Now,
suffering from a touch of dyslexia, as I do I was quite interested in context
sensitive spell checking software, although I was also a bit dubious. Would it
detect ‘theme’ instead of ‘them,’ possibly. But how about ‘bed’ instead of
‘bead’ ... probably no so much. Anyway I decided to have a look and begun some
on-line trawling for example/demo applications.
Wednesday, 1 February 2012
Bloging is writing to...
That may sound like an obvious and redundant statement, but after
recently discussing this I was amazed by how many people don’t seem to make the
connection.
I suppose it all depends on what type of blogs you primarily
read. I mostly ether read about writing from writers, or about gaming – from gamers,
and yes there is a general difference in
both presentation and style. That’s not to say the writing blogs are always
better written. I’ve read some very professional sounding and eloquent gaming
blogs. Remember that most gamers, and perhaps especially most of the ones that have
a blog, are at least in their mid twenties, and statistically most gamers are
above thirty. Not the spotty teenagers writing in text speak that the media
would have you believe they are.
I’m sure we all know that Blog is a concatenation of ‘’Web Log”
and unfortunately there are bloggers that do exactly that... log their daily endeavours,
or lack there off, onto their blog. But that’s no different from the same type
of accounts on Facebook or Twitter. And where this type if thing is getting increasingly
prevalent on those types of site, the rambling shambling blog is becoming rarer
all the time, as better outlets become available for this type of ‘personal log’
site...
Thursday, 5 January 2012
Book tokens for Christmas.
As usual I got a certain amount of book tokens for Christmas again this year... well I say ‘book tokens’ but it’s not really old-fashioned, redeemable at the store ‘book tokens’ anymore it is? What I got were gift-cards, credit-card sized pieces of plastic with arbitrated amounts of money, and wishes of ‘buy something you like’ attributed to them. All too often this translates to ‘buy something that I can see is worth the amount of money I gave you.’ This isn’t to say that the gesture wasn’t genuine and sincere. However most people give a ‘token’ with the intention of the recipient getting something tangible that they (the sender) can see the person will actually like, and/or enjoy. And this is of course totally understandable. They don’t want you to waist or squander their gift. This sometimes brings a bit of a dilemma for me though. The good thing about these gift-cards is that most can easily be used for on-line purchases. Often what I want to do is use the gift-cards on-line to buy e-books, and not necessarily all at once directly after Christmas. Unfortunately this doesn’t really give me anything to ‘show’ for my gift. And has resulted in some confused or even sorrowful looks from the gifters, along this half hearted comments of ‘Oh, well if that’s what you wanted...’ The other side of this of course is when I show them a shiny new, and importantly thick, coffee-table book full of full-colour pictures, then their face will light up with the ‘gift’ they have got me.
I know it’s not exactly an earth shattering dilemma, and sometimes I’ll just get a ‘real’ paper-based book or books to approximately the same value as the gift-card and say I got those with it, keeping the card to use for on-line purchases for convenience. As it means I don’t have to use my bank-card on-line. That way everybody is happy.
Let me tell you a story...
I’ve been looking at some of the critiques I’ve received lately, and the old ‘show don’t tell’ seemed to be back with a vengeance. This could just be my rubbish writing of course, but I took a look at some critiques of other peoples work, on various sites, as well and they do all seem to latch onto the same things. This would be a good thing if all this ‘tell’ was indeed dry and slowing down the story. But it’s also an easy target.
If you read any book from one of the latest popular mainstream ‘blockbuster’ series, like Twilight or Harry Potter for example, they are full of ‘tell’ sections. Not that I’m saying this is inherently a bad thing, or bad writing.
I don’t think I’d like to read a book that is entirely written in ‘show’ and the popular authors certainly don’t write like this. Like everything in writing, I suppose the trick is to strike the right balance.
So going back to those critique sites. I don’t think a lot of people are looking for or getting that balance. And please don’t think I’m trying to defend my own writing here. I’m most definitely not, and I look at and take every comment I get very seriously, whether it’s from a good-selling author or a complete (hence usually very keen) beginner. I totally believe that everybody’s opinion counts.
I also don’t think most people are picking faults in their critiques with any malice, after all a good critique is supposed to pick holes in your writing. No, I think it’s more that writers, especially the complete beginners nowadays are being more and more bombarded with the same old ... truisms ... e.g ‘Show don’t tell,’ ‘always use active and not passive voice,’ ‘kill the ..lly.’ All snappy little titbits of wisdom, but they may also make people too focused on the technical mechanics of writing without sufficient regard to the ebb and flow of the overall story.
I try not to look for examples in my own work because it’s too subjective, but I have seen numerous examples of what I see as selective critiquing on other peoples writing. I’ve read sections that seem to flow perfectly well to me, but people have hit time and again on an often small ‘tell’ section with the standard ‘Show this, I want to see xxx yyy’ comments. Often my thoughts run along the lines of ‘Why would you want to see that? If you read the story you can plainly see it’s simple background information, and doesn’t play a major part in ether the plot nor the character development.’ I suspect that a lot of the time the honest answer would be ‘Well I saw a bit of tell and told them to show, like you are supposed to do.’ And I believe in all honesty that they are trying to do good.
Wednesday, 4 January 2012
Popular, esteemed, and accomplished...
I received two Terry Pratchett books at Christmas, one by him (Snuff) and one about him. And I asked, well hinted heavily, for the second one. Anyone who knows me will tell you ‘I don’t read autobiographies.’ So why, you may ask, did I want this book. Well I’d unashamedly say that the Discworld books are my favourite series, the only other series coming close would be the original Douglas Adams ‘Hitchhiker's Guide’ books.
Because of this I’ve developer at least a passing interest in the people who wrote these books, again something not particularly in my nature. Most times I would read a book without any interest in the author, like I would watch a film without any interest in the scriptwriters, director, or actors. But some people do stand out. I could only name a handful of actors, and I am only interested in about the same amount of authors.
A critic may say ‘you are interested in Pratchett because he is popular,’ and that may very well be true. But critics seem to all too often, and ready, to attribute popularity with some distain somehow. And I would argue that popularity in and of itself isn’t what made an author interesting to me, no that would be their work...
I wouldn’t dream of knocking J.K. Rowling’s work and she is definitely a very popular author, but that doesn’t make me personally interested in her books or in her as an author. I mean no disrespect, and it’s understandable because I was never in her target readership group. So what makes Pratchett, or Adams different for me?
To be honest it’s a hard question to answer. I like the work of other authors, in the same way I like the work of some actors or directors, but I have no interest in any of them as people.
I think this is where the ‘esteemed’ factor comes in, at least for me. I personally hold the work of some authors in higher esteem than most. Unlike professional critics I get to be entirely subjective in this choice, and I don’t need to justify anything past the fact that ‘I like it’ and the same holds true for all those ‘Harry Potter’ and ‘Twilight’ fans out there. We do not have any ‘thought police’ (at least not yet) and I personally think some people should remember that a bit more.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

